contentSutra.com - India\'s Digital News Monitor

Current Story

Google Mobile Phone To Enter India?

By Rafat Ali - Thu 23 Aug 2007 05:05 PM PST

Possibly the most error-ridden story I’ve read in a while: Business Standard has a very speculative story on Google’s supposed phone (dubbed Gphone), and how it has started talks with operators in India for an exclusive launch on one of their networks. It says that talks are being held with Bharti Airtel, Vodafone Essar and BSNL. I think the writers have confused Google mobile service, for which it might be talking to the operators, with Gphone, which is nowhere near any state of readiness to launch in U.S., much less an Asian country.

Some bad errors:
-- It is believed to be a fortnight away from the worldwide launch of its much-awaited Google Phone(Gphone). Then, down the story, it says US regulatory approval, which is expected soon, is the only hurdle that Google is waiting to cross. If and when it is approved, it will take along time to launch in U.S.....then it would have to go through local country approvals, which will again take a long time.
-- It says:Google plans to invest $7-8 billion for its global telephony foray. And then, down the story, it quotes a WSJ story from last month which said Google had invested “hundreds of millions of dollars” in the project. Wide off the mark.
-- It says: Globally, Google is likely to participate in the upcoming auction for 700 MHz spectrum. This is NOT globally, only U.S. spectrum...there is no such thing as global spectrum. Wrong again.

All in all, a ridiculous story, written and edited badly.

Update: More misleading stuff, pointed out in this comment on Rediff.com (which republished the BS story):  First it says that Google is fortnight (15 days) away from launching phone. Then it says that “...Google has developed a prototype that will hit the markets in a year’s time.”. 

Posted in: Companies, Google, Mobile


Related Research from Alacrastore.com

7 Responses:
  • From Aseem Bajaj Thu 23 Aug 2007 05:55 PM

    You missed the astute observation: “Ironically, Google recently partnered Apple to produce services such as e-mail and maps for its iPhone handset.”

  • From manish jain Thu 23 Aug 2007 06:46 PM

    at least it didn’t go down the path of saying ... “and bollywood star XYZ has been rumored to be the brand ambassador.”

  • From Nikhil Thu 23 Aug 2007 06:57 PM

    Naah...that would have been ET. :D

  • From Ram Thu 23 Aug 2007 07:37 PM

    Well said!

  • From Deep throat Thu 23 Aug 2007 08:40 PM

    Hi ,

    A trustable source inside IMI mobile says that IMI has got the google mobile deal, wherein IMI will be responsible for integrating the connectivity across various networks in India. ( Apparently IMI also manages the yahoo shortcode) !

  • From VAS-Guy Fri 24 Aug 2007 09:10 PM

    YooHoo!
    I am sure lots of journalists are challenged understanding this whole mobile/digital media/VAS business.

    One of the main reasons which makes CS, a default destination for new media business news instead of such newspaper’s sites.

    BTW, BS can be spelt as B**l S**t too wink Oops, sorry big guys!

  • From BlogsDNA Fri 20 Jun 2008 07:55 AM

    Wow.. Google Targeting India thats really big thing for us, i would love if google can get some good broadband service for india users smile

Post Your Comment

Mobile Options

» Mobile App
» Mobile/WAP Site

Send a News Tip

About

contentSutra.com is a news site covering India's digital content market.

Rafat Ali
Publisher

Cerius Shah
Contributing Writer

EconCeleb Conference - The Economics of Celebrity. July 23 at the Roosevelt Hotel in Hollywood

Featured Report - 2008 Social Media Deals Report

front page of report

The economics of social media continue to heat up, with ever more buzz created in new and growing market categories. This report examines the categories, number and size of investment and acquisitions into social media and the resulting value created from 2007 through 2008. Order your report today to analyze deals made by Yahoo, Disney, Google, AOL, CBS, Hearst, Microsoft and many more.

Learn more or purchase now.

Recently on paidContent.org

Jobs

New Media/Interactive Job Listings

Post Job
More Jobs

Generous Supporters