contentSutra.com - India\'s Digital News Monitor

Current Story

NDTV Tries Answers With Ammas.com

By Nikhil Pahwa - Sun 06 Jan 2008 11:10 PM PST

[by Cerius Shah] After Yahoo (NSDQ: YHOO), Ask and Rediff (NSDQ: REDF) its NDTV Convergence getting into the business of free advice with NDTV Answers. According to this E4M story there are a panel of experts who address queries based on their area of specialization and an existing network that generates an average of over six quality-filtered responses per query, with nearly 300,000 registered advisors and over 830,000 articles of quality-filtered advice. The service itself is powered by Ammas.com and everything from the traffic to the back-end is supported by or through Ammas. In fact, you wouldn’t even know the difference between the answers section on Amma’s vs NDTV if it weren’t for the banner telling you so.

The system works on a leaderboard mechanism where answers are ranked for relevance and answers as well as good questions are rewarded with AA$ (Ask Agent Dollars). AA$ earned can be used for shopping or exchanged for USD through the Ask-Ex trade system. AA$ is supported by Sifymall.com, a user can cash in his reward for goods from the material realm as well.

Few things. First, asking a question shouldn’t involve a penalty. Putting in a priority system that penalizes the user on his first experience gives out the wrong signal. Secondly, the system defeats the purpose of a prompt reply. If you have a query which is top priority for you to be answered, but you don’t have the cash to get that attention, you have to buy AA$ using real Benjamin’s or go around giving advice yourself. The system rewards people for giving answers not for asking questions. Unless someone is really hungry for that reversible winter jacket, I don’t see too many people asking questions at NDTV Answers.

Nikhil adds: I wonder how long NDTVs deal with Ammas is for: remember the Yello Media’s tie-up for NDTVjobs.com? Since that partnership dissolved, NDTVjobs hasn’t resurfaced (the url redirects to NDTV.com) and Yellojobs has gone solo.

Posted in: Companies, NDTV, Portals



Related Research from Alacrastore.com
Comments Are Not Allowed For This Article
  • From puchoo Sun 06 Jan 2008 11:44 PM

    o a direct copy of the idea that is Yahoo answers. No originality.. expressindia copied it, now NDTV…and then we ask why we dont have enough “global” indian websites.

  • From nishant Mon 07 Jan 2008 12:20 AM

    Hi Cerius,
    I wonder why you say the system rewards for giving answers and not for asking questions?—the site says the system rewards AA dollars for asking good questions.
    Nishant

  • From Cerius Mon 07 Jan 2008 01:29 AM

    Hi Nishant,

    Have mentioned it in the second paragraph that good questions are rewarded. . While a good answer can be easily discerned based on its ability to solve a problem, the definition of a good question is subjective.

    Rewards for good questions mean that ANY question is not rewarded. There are more people willing to impart advice rather than receive it.

    Hope that answers your question (pun intended)

  • From Pravin Mon 07 Jan 2008 02:08 AM

    This link clearly shows the reward system. Good Question is not subjective.
    http://www.ammas.com/aa/ask/popup_queryrewards.cfm

  • From sunandini Mon 07 Jan 2008 03:48 AM

    what is your opinion of ibibo sawaal?

  • From Singha Mon 07 Jan 2008 06:04 PM

    no, Puchoo, Ammas came before any of those players —Yahoo answers, Ask, Rediff answers, etc.  And unlike Yahoo and Ask, Ammas started in India!!!  So we should give NDTV credit for going with highest quality product rather than brand name and marketing hype.

  • From Zombie Tue 08 Jan 2008 04:15 AM

    The problem with ndtv is that they have been launching websites without having a long term plan/vision about developing them and transforming them into brands.

    In a hurry to scale-up, basic things like having a development plan to develop a product or future strategies are not in place. So the idea that they will innovate is totally misplaced.

    Look at the sites they have launched in last six months. their cricket site is a perfect example. It looks like they are competing with Web18 in launching websites, but the only difference is that the quality of Web18 is much superior.

  • From rishi Tue 08 Jan 2008 07:17 AM

    Hilarious.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J4upi5qDxhQ

Mobile Options

» Mobile App
» Mobile/WAP Site

Send a News Tip

About

contentSutra.com is a news site covering India's digital content market.

Rafat Ali
Publisher

Cerius Shah
Contributing Writer

FOBM Conference - Oct 28 | Edison Ballroom | NYC

Recently on paidContent.org

Jobs

New Media/Interactive Job Listings

Post Job
More Jobs

Generous Supporters